I have a 1st print Buffalo Castle that I saved from the old days. Ken St. Andre said it probably wasn't worth that much, not like a 1st print T&T. What does everyone think about that? I'd be interested to know.
                                                    Tom

I can hear the boo's from over here. Give him the HOOK!
                                             Tom

You guys crack me up… We've got some old T&T stuff, the copied kind with the spiral bindings. The real treat is a minty 2nd print of T&T…the one only sold at Origins 2.

As far as value on the T&T stuff it varies, of yet I just don't think it's well organized enough as far as collecting goes. It is a first print though...so that always attracts attention on just about any older RPG…

Best of luck if you decide to part with it, but I'd hang on to it. T&T was always fun, and as RPG collecting grows there will be more attention to the D&D spin-offs.  JMO

Mike

tntwargo wrote:I don't plan on selling my Buffalo Castle because of the sentimental value. I was just curious as to what others thought of it. It is not spiral bound, but seperate pages held together with 2 staples. It has a light blue cover. On the top of page one it says:

Buffalo Castle
By Rick Loomis, from an idea by Steve McAllister
               Copyright 1976 by Flying Buffalo Inc.

Here is a clickable scan of the cover:

[ Image ]

What do you think?
                        Tom

The staples indicate it's one of the first three printings of the 1st edition; pretty cool!  It's one of the very first RPG items by any company ever released, so if nothing else I'd hold onto it for the sentimental value you talk about as T&T stuff is seriously undervalued right now.  You'd never get what is is actually worth, but it's a nice piece of gaming history to own.

Mike B.

Hmmm, I'll have to go compare that my copies of BC and Dungeon of the Bear (exact title?), which weren't bound at all IIRC, and were in ziplocks I think....

invincibleoverlord wrote:I just don't think it's well organized enough as far as collecting goes.

This is exactly right. T&T has some rare and unique collectibles and still has some rabid fans, but there's been no serious attempt (AFAIK) to pull all of the data together in an effort to make some sense of it all. There's certainly nothing even remotely as organized as The Acaeum.

One interesting note, though: a serious collector could probably secure a copy of every professionally-printed T&T product ever made (starting from scratch, my guess is it would take between 1 and 2 years). There's just not that much material, especially as compared to D&D/AD&D.

tntwargo wrote:This website is very useful and I am certainly glad I joined the Forums.
Mike, is there any way to tell which of the 1st three printings that Buffalo Castle is? There doesn't seem to be any print number info.
I know this website is about collecting, but would it be out of line to start a thread about interesting gaming sessions that people could relate?
I sure wish there was a site like this for wargames.
             -Tom

Tom;

The information I have on T&T I take from Lawrence Schick's must-have reference book, Heroic Worlds.  It states that the 1st three printings (1976) were stapled, while printings 4th-11th (1977) were in black spiral binding, no differentiation noted between printings.  So it looks like you'd have to probably talk to one of the T&T publishers from way back when to see if they remembered what told the printings apart.  I once had a first printing of T&T's Naked Doom (1977) that I sold a long time ago, I really loved it because it looked like it was put together in someone's basement! (and it probably was!)
    General Collecting is usually a pretty good place for general musings about gaming type nostalgia  :D

Mike B.

I actually started playing TnT just prior to learning about D&D through some friends.
From time to time, I ebay stuff out of sentimentality. It is a great trip down memory lane. At some point I wll get serious and put a collection together of the real old stuff. Comparitively, it is cheap.
I'd keep that BC. Your just not gonna see much return in selling it. It is worth more in your collection than a few bucks in your checking account. Just my two cents...